For two thousand years, the central theological question dividing Judaism and Christianity has been the identity of Jesus of Nazareth. At the heart of this debate are the Hebrew Scriptures—what Christians call the Old Testament.
Christian theology maintains that Jesus fulfilled hundreds of specific prophecies recorded centuries before his birth. Conversely, traditional rabbinic Judaism argues that Christians have mistranslated the Hebrew text, ripped verses out of their historical context, and overlooked the fact that Jesus did not bring about the Messianic Age of universal peace.
Below is a comprehensive look at 15 of the most prominent Old Testament passages used in this debate, examining how traditional Jewish commentators interpret them and how Christian apologists respond to those arguments.
The Torah (The Books of Moses)
1. Genesis 3:15 – The Seed of the Woman
“And I will put enmity between you and the woman, and between your offspring and hers; he will crush your head, and you will strike his heel.”
- The Jewish View: Traditional Jewish commentators like Rashi view this verse strictly as a natural, literal explanation for why humans and snakes are enemies. Because the word “offspring” (zera) is collective, they argue it simply means humanity will always try to crush snakes’ heads, while snakes will bite humans’ heels.
- The Christian Response: Christian scholars point out a striking grammatical anomaly in the Hebrew: while zera (offspring) can be collective, the text switches to a singular masculine pronoun—he (hu) will crush your head. Furthermore, snakes do not strike only heels, nor is “seed of the woman” standard Hebrew phrasing (lineage was always traced through the father). Notably, ancient Jewish Aramaic translations (the Targums) actually interpreted this passage messianically, stating that the descendants of the woman would find healing “in the days of the King Messiah.”
2. Genesis 49:10 – The Scepter of Judah
“The scepter will not depart from Judah, nor the ruler’s staff from between his feet, until he to whom it belongs [Shiloh] shall come and the obedience of the nations shall be his.”
- The Jewish View: Medieval commentators like Ibn Ezra and Rashbam argued that “the scepter” refers to King David’s dynasty, and “until Shiloh comes” simply means until David arrives at the town of Shiloh, or until the Messiah eventually comes to restore the monarchy that was lost centuries ago.
- The Christian Response: The word ad (“until”) indicates a boundary in time: Judah would retain tribal identity and legal authority until the Messiah came, after which it would depart. Historically, Judah maintained its tribal governance and judicial authority (the Sanhedrin’s power over capital punishment) even through the Babylonian exile—until roughly 6–7 CE, when Rome stripped Judea of the right to execute criminals, shortly before Jesus began his ministry. Even the Babylonian Talmud (Sanhedrin 98b) lists “Shiloh” as one of the names of the Messiah.
3. Numbers 24:17 – The Star Out of Jacob
“I see him, but not now; I behold him, but not near. A star will come out of Jacob; a scepter will rise out of Israel. He will crush the foreheads of Moab…”
- The Jewish View: Rabbinic commentators generally agree this is a messianic prophecy, though some apply an initial fulfillment to King David (who defeated Moab). However, they argue that because Jesus did not militarily conquer Israel’s surrounding enemies, he cannot be the figure described here.
- The Christian Response: Christian apologists note that the prophecy begins with “I see him, but not now; I behold him, but not near,” pointing far beyond King David’s era. While David defeated Moab physically, Christians view the conquering of Moab and Edom in prophetic literature as symbolic of the Messiah’s ultimate triumph over all nations hostile to God—a victory inaugurated spiritually through the gospel’s spread to the Gentiles and completed at Christ’s second coming.
4. Deuteronomy 18:15–19 – A Prophet Like Moses
“The Lord your God will raise up for you a prophet like me from among you, from your fellow Israelites. You must listen to him.”
- The Jewish View: Rashi and Ibn Ezra contend that “a prophet” does not refer to one specific individual, but rather to a continuous succession of prophets (starting with Joshua, then Jeremiah, Isaiah, etc.) whom God would send to guide Israel so they wouldn’t turn to pagan diviners.
- The Christian Response: While God did send many prophets, Deuteronomy 34:10 explicitly states: “Since then, no prophet has risen in Israel like Moses, whom the Lord knew face to face.” None of the later prophets were “like Moses.” Jesus uniquely mirrors Moses: both survived a king’s slaughter of infant boys, both spent time in Egypt, both mediated a covenant between God and the people, both performed unprecedented signs and wonders, and both spoke directly with God.
The Prophets (Isaiah, Micah, Zechariah)
5. Isaiah 7:14 – The “Virgin” Birth
“Therefore the Lord himself will give you a sign: The virgin will conceive and give birth to a son, and will call him Immanuel.”
- The Jewish View: Jewish commentators raise two objections. First, the Hebrew word is almah (“young woman of childbearing age”), not betulah (“virgin”). Second, the prophecy was given to King Ahaz during a military crisis, meaning the child had to be born in Ahaz’s lifetime (such as his son Hezekiah) to serve as a relevant sign.
- The Christian Response: In the Hebrew Bible, almah is never used for a married woman; in ancient Israelite culture, an unmarried young woman was assumed to be a virgin. More importantly, two centuries before Jesus, Jewish scholars translated the Hebrew Bible into Greek (the Septuagint) and translated almah as parthenos—a Greek word that exclusively means “virgin.” Additionally, a routine birth to a young married woman would hardly qualify as a miraculous “sign” from the Lord (v. 11). Christians recognize a dual fulfillment: an immediate, partial sign for Ahaz, and an ultimate, miraculous fulfillment in Christ.
6. Isaiah 9:6–7 – The Divine Child
“For to us a child is born, to us a son is given… And he will be called Wonderful Counselor, Mighty God, Everlasting Father, Prince of Peace.”
- The Jewish View: To avoid attributing divine titles to a human Messiah, commentators like Rashi argue that God is the one doing the naming here—meaning “The Wonderful Counselor, the Mighty God, the Everlasting Father calls his name ‘Prince of Peace.’” They typically identify this child as King Hezekiah.
- The Christian Response: Apologists point out that this reading breaks standard Hebrew grammar. Throughout the Old Testament, when the verb vayikra (“and he called”) is used in naming formulas, the subject is never separated by four long divine titles before reaching the name. Furthermore, verse 7 states that “of the greatness of his government and peace there will be no end” as he reigns “from that time on and forever.” Hezekiah’s reign was temporary, flawed, and followed by national collapse; only an eternal, divine Messiah fulfills this description.
7. Isaiah 52:13 – 53:12 – The Suffering Servant
“But he was pierced for our transgressions, he was crushed for our iniquities; the punishment that brought us peace was on him, and by his wounds we are healed.” (Isaiah 53:5)
- The Jewish View: Following Rashi in the 11th century, the dominant Jewish interpretation is that the “Servant” is a personification of the Jewish people suffering unjustly at the hands of Gentile nations throughout exile.
- The Christian Response: The text repeatedly distinguishes the Servant from the nation of Israel. In Isaiah 53:8, the Servant is stricken “for the transgression of my people.” Israel cannot die for its own sins. Moreover, the Servant is completely sinless (“he had done no violence, nor was any deceit in his mouth,” v. 9) and suffers willingly without resistance—a stark contrast to how Isaiah describes the nation of Israel elsewhere (e.g., Isaiah 1:4, “a sinful nation, a people whose guilt is great”). Notably, early rabbinic sources—including the Targum Jonathan and the Talmud (Sanhedrin 98b)—explicitly identified Isaiah 53 as referring to the Messiah before medieval polemics shifted the view.
8. Micah 5:2 – Ruler from Bethlehem
“But you, Bethlehem Ephrathah, though you are small among the clans of Judah, out of you will come for me one who will be ruler over Israel, whose origins are from of old, from ancient times.”
- The Jewish View: Jewish commentators agree this refers to the Messiah, who must be a descendant of King David (whose family came from Bethlehem). However, they argue Jesus failed to fulfill the rest of the passage, which describes the Messiah bringing immediate political security and world peace.
- The Christian Response: Christians highlight the second half of the verse: “whose origins are from of old, from ancient times” (which in Hebrew, mimei olam, can mean “from days of eternity”). This points to a Messiah who existed before his human birth in Bethlehem. Regarding world peace, Christians argue that the prophets present two distinct messianic roles: the Suffering Servant who atones for sin at his first coming, and the Conquering King who establishes global peace at his return.
9. Zechariah 9:9 – The Humble King on a Donkey
“Rejoice greatly, Daughter Zion!… See, your king comes to you, righteous and victorious, lowly and riding on a donkey, on a colt, the foal of a donkey.”
- The Jewish View: Rabbis acknowledge this is a messianic prophecy. The Talmud (Sanhedrin 98a) famously reconciles this humble image with Daniel’s vision of the Messiah coming “on the clouds of heaven” by saying: if Israel is worthy, the Messiah will come on the clouds; if Israel is unworthy, he will come lowly, riding on a donkey.
- The Christian Response: Christian scholars note that this verse creates a major hurdle for traditional Jewish expectations of a purely political, conquering Messiah. Why would a conquering military general enter Jerusalem on a humble donkey? Jesus’s Triumphal Entry intentionally fulfilled Zechariah 9:9 to demonstrate that his first mission was one of peace and spiritual redemption, preceding his future return in glory.
10. Zechariah 12:10 – Looking on the Pierced One
“And I will pour out on the house of David and the inhabitants of Jerusalem a spirit of grace and supplication. They will look on me, the one they have pierced, and they will mourn for him as one mourns for an only child…”
- The Jewish View: Rashi and others interpret the “pierced” ones as Jewish soldiers—or specifically Mashiach ben Yosef (a secondary, non-Davidic Messiah figure in rabbinic tradition)—who will be killed in the final Gog and Magog war, causing Israel to mourn.
- The Christian Response: Apologists point closely to the pronouns in the Hebrew text: God is the speaker in this chapter (“I will pour out…”), yet God says, “They will look on me, the one they have pierced, and they will mourn for him.” This mysterious shift between “me” (God) and “him” (a pierced human figure) aligns directly with the Christian doctrine of the incarnation—where piercing the Messiah is synonymous with piercing God Himself.
The Writings (Psalms and Daniel)
11. Psalm 2:7 – The Begotten Son
“I will proclaim the Lord’s decree: He said to me, ‘You are my son; today I have become your father.’”
- The Jewish View: Commentators view this as a coronation psalm written for King David or Solomon. In ancient Near Eastern culture, Israel’s kings were metaphorically called God’s “sons” upon taking the throne, without implying literal divinity.
- The Christian Response: While Psalm 2 had an immediate context in Israel’s monarchy, its language goes far beyond any historical king of Israel. No Israelite king was ever promised “the nations [as] your inheritance, the ends of the earth your possession” (v. 8), nor were all kings of the earth warned to “kiss his son, or he will be angry and your way will lead to your destruction… Blessed are all who take refuge in him” (v. 12). In the Old Testament, taking refuge in a mere mortal is forbidden (Jeremiah 17:5); taking refuge in this Son indicates his divine status.
12. Psalm 16:8–11 – Victory Over Decay
“Therefore my heart is glad and my tongue rejoices; my body also will rest secure, because you will not abandon me to the realm of the dead, nor will you let your faithful one see decay.”
- The Jewish View: Jewish commentators argue that King David is simply expressing confidence that God will protect his life from immediate danger and keep him from dying prematurely at the hands of his enemies.
- The Christian Response: As the Apostle Peter argued in Acts 2, King David eventually died, was buried, and his body did see physical decay—his tomb was still in Jerusalem centuries later. Because David was a prophet, Christians argue that the Holy Spirit spoke through David’s words to point ultimately to the Messiah, whose body did not undergo decay in the grave because he rose on the third day.
13. Psalm 22:1–18 – Pierced Hands and Feet
“Dogs surround me, a pack of villains encircles me; they pierce my hands and my feet… They divide my clothes among them and cast lots for my garment.”
- The Jewish View: Jewish scholars argue that “they pierce” is a Christian mistranslation. In the standard Hebrew Masoretic Text, the word is ka’ari, which means “like a lion” (“like a lion, [they are at] my hands and my feet”). They also view the psalm as David’s poetic metaphor for feeling surrounded by enemies.
- The Christian Response: Older manuscripts predating the Masoretic Text (which was standardized between the 7th and 10th centuries CE) overturn the “like a lion” objection. Both the Greek Septuagint (translated 200+ years before Jesus) and a 1st-century Hebrew scroll found at Nahal Hever among the Dead Sea Scrolls read “they pierced” (ka’aru). Furthermore, nothing in King David’s biography remotely parallels someone piercing his hands and feet or gambling for his clothes—making it a remarkably specific preview of Roman crucifixion centuries before crucifixion was even invented.
14. Psalm 110:1 – David’s Lord
“The Lord says to my lord: ‘Sit at my right hand until I make your enemies a footstool for your feet.’”
- The Jewish View: To avoid the implication that David is calling the Messiah “Lord,” Rashi and other medieval commentators argue that the psalm was not written by David, but about David (or Abraham) by a court musician—so the singer is referring to King David himself as “my lord.”
- The Christian Response: The Hebrew superscription explicitly states LeDavid Mizmor (“A Psalm of David”), the exact same phrasing used across dozens of other psalms universally recognized as written by David. Furthermore, verse 4 declares that this figure is “a priest forever, in the order of Melchizedek.” Under Mosaic Law, no king from the tribe of Judah (like David) could ever serve as a priest—only a unique, transcendent Messiah could unite the offices of King and High Priest.
15. Daniel 9:24–27 – The Seventy Weeks Timeline
“From the time the word goes out to restore and rebuild Jerusalem until the Anointed One, the ruler, comes, there will be seven ‘sevens,’ and sixty-two ‘sevens.’ … After the sixty-two ‘sevens,’ the Anointed One will be put to death and will have nothing. The people of the ruler who will come will destroy the city and the sanctuary.”
- The Jewish View: Jewish commentators calculate the 490 years (“seventy weeks” of years) differently, arguing the timeline concludes either during the Maccabean revolt (2nd century BCE) or at the Roman destruction of Jerusalem in 70 CE. They identify the “anointed one” (mashiach) as the High Priest Onias III or King Agrippa II, rather than the Messiah.
- The Christian Response: Christian scholars point to two decisive details in the text. First, verse 24 states the ultimate goal of this 490-year period is to “put an end to sin, to atone for wickedness, [and] to bring in everlasting righteousness”—none of which happened during the Maccabean revolt or through a corrupt ruler like Agrippa II. Second, the text establishes an unbreakable chronological sequence: the Anointed One comes and is “cut off” (executed), and after that, the city and the Temple (sanctuary) are destroyed. Since the Second Temple was destroyed in 70 CE, the Messiah had to appear and die before 70 CE.
Conclusion
When viewed individually, each of these passages sparks intense linguistic and historical debate. Yet for Christians, the power of Old Testament prophecy lies in its cumulative weight. Taken together, these 15 passages sketch a remarkably cohesive portrait: a figure from the tribe of Judah, born in Bethlehem, preceded by a miraculous sign, who would arrive before the destruction of the Second Temple, be rejected and pierced for the sins of his people, conquer death without seeing decay, and ultimately rule over all nations. For Christians, there is only one figure in human history who fits every piece of that puzzle: Jesus of Nazareth.


Leave a Reply